Friday, March 29, 2013

Overthinking Star Wars: Them Changes, Part 3

Continued from Part 2

The Empire Strikes Back

Snow Monster

The snow creature - known as the wampa -breaks the neck of Luke’s mount (tauntaun), and knocks Luke out.  When Luke is in the cave, we see a new CG wampa munching away - probably on Luke’s tauntaun.  But the reason that he’s probably eating now is because even though he’s got probably the greatest and most energy efficient freezer, he probably doesn't have a grill or an outlet to plug the microwave in.  Or a microwave.  Or a conventional oven.  But I would think Luke would be eaten first because he is smaller and thus could be savored as an appetizer.  Maybe he’s going to be dessert.  Anyway, Luke is able to obtain his lightsaber through the Force, frees himself, and slices the creature’s arm off.  

the force.net
Profile view of a VERY, VERY, recently amputated wampa. 

The Blu-Ray bonus disc reveals wampas had a more visible role because they had broken into the base.  But these creatures looked more, well, fake. Like some evil albino cousins of Sully from Monsters, Inc.


Matte Lines

This is a technical area, and like I said, I’m not much of a technical person.  But I have to respect the special (optical) effects guys pulling off the challenging snow battle. The difficulty is that they were working with white backgrounds, and this was a challenge at the time.  One of the main problems was that the snow scenes would show through the black lines in the cockpit canopy.   Normally, you could hide this in a space battle, because the cockpit lines would simply be black on black.  Not so with the snow.  You had to make a choice about how much scenery you’re willing to see at the expense of the solid canopy line.  So ILM now got to fill in the black so that the cockpit lines are black and the scenery shows up.


Blue Artoo

I didn’t realize this until it was pointed out on a web page that I’m not sure exists anymore on this site.  When Artoo’s in the back seat in the X-wing in the original theatrical release, he’s actually black instead of blue.  The reason why is because that’s filmed against a bluescreen.  If Artoo was in his standard blue, he would be a victim of what is known as bluespill.  That would mean his blue parts would seem transparent, and we want ALL of Artoo there, don’t we?  Now the effects people can paint in the blue, or have a CG Artoo.


The Emperor

Ian McDiarmid, who plays Senator/Chancellor/Emperor Palpatine in the other movies except for A New Hope, is inserted into the Empire Strikes Back.

biobreak.wordpress.com
Originally, the Emperor had been a woman’s face superimposed with chimpanzee’s eyes and voiced by Clive Revill.
icollector.com
It made for a pretty eerie effect, but alas, continuity triumphs. But besides continuity, there is a slight, but significant change in the dialogue:

Original theatrical dialogue:
Emperor: We have a new enemy, Luke Skywalker.  He could destroy us.
Vader: He’s just a boy.  Obi-Wan can no longer help him.
Revised DVD dialogue:
Emperor:  We have a new enemy.  The young rebel who destroyed the Death Star.  I have no doubt this boy is the offspring of Anakin Skywalker.
Vader:  How is that possible?
Emperor: Search your feelings, Lord Vader.  You will know it to be true.  He could destroy us.
Vader: He’s just a boy.  Obi-Wan can no longer help him.

We see that in the revised dialogue, there’s something going on, given the opening crawl mentions that Vader is “obsessed with finding young Skywalker” and that, upon seeing the rebel base’s power generators transmitted from the probe droid, says “I am sure Skywalker is with them.”  This dialogue with Palpy implies that Vader is playing dumb and is up to something behind the Emperor’s back.  We remember from the prequels, agonizingly for some, that Anakin entered a Faustian pact and really lost everything from it except for being relatively well-placed in the Empire’s food chain.  And I would think that threatening, torturing, and choking wouldn’t lead to total job satisfaction or life fulfillment. Plus there's that faith of some "there is still good in him." At any rate, Vader may be seeing Luke as his ticket out of this mess.


Boba Fett

Again, continuity wins out.  Since Boba Fett is an exact clone of Jango Fett, who was played by Temuera Morrison, it only makes sense that Morrison would be voicing Boba Fett.  I miss hearing Jason Wingreen’s awesomely villainous voice, but Temuera Morrison’s doesn’t sound bad, either.  Certainly not enough to say my childhood has been violated.


Cloud City

We get an expanded view of Cloud City.  First, that additional scenery makes it longer for the Millennium Falcon to land.  Then the additional scene makes it longer to get an establishing shot of Leia in her new outfit pacing in the tower.  On the other hand, additional scenery makes the corridors not seem so claustrophobic and sterile.  So maybe that’s a good thing.  I don’t know.


Vader’s (Grrrrr) Return to His Ship

All right, this is where I put on my fanboy hat.  This first beef I have is with Vader's revised command for his shuttle.  What was wrong with keeping, “bring my shuttle?”  It was no-nonsense, and conveyed some anger on Vader’s part.  In the Special Edition, the line is changed to, “alert my star destroyer to prepare for my arrival.”  What kind of line is that?  And although relevant documentary evidence has long since vanished from the starwars.com web site, that’s not James Earl Jones’ voice.  If I remember correctly, it was an ILM-er, perhaps Don Bies.  A word of advice to anyone who wants to re-create a Vader scene: DO NOT under ANY CIRCUMSTANCES attempt to do so without James Earl Jones’ voice.


patheos.com


OK, so sometimes it doesn't always work even with James Earl Jones' voice.

Then Vader lands on what is supposedly his star destroyer.  I think Lucas et al may have underestimated the fanaticism of their fanatics, that we have seen Return of the Jedi many, many, many times.  We know this arrival is an alternate angle scene from when Vader lands on Death Star II.  This fan-made video does a pretty good job at convincingly inter-cutting the footage from Return of the Jedi and the Empire Strikes Back (the side views).


Pretty seamless, I’d say.  To me there's just no reason to establish him landing on his star destroyer.  I saw it as a 12-year-old for the first time, and I always assumed he got a little ride to his BIG ride.  No explanation necessary.


Next: Return of the Jedi


No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated for this blog.