Tuesday, April 2, 2013

Overthinking Star Wars: Them Changes, Part 4


Return of the Jedi

Continued from Part 3

Jabba’s Palace Entrance

In the Blu-Ray, the door to Jabba’s palace is bigger.  What, to show this is a big place?  I think we already got that impression before with the echoing door shutting.

Lapti Nek vs. Jedi Rocks

These are the names given to the musical numbers in the pre-Special Edition and Special Edition, respectively.  The question is: Who really cares?  I didn’t like either number but I guess an immobile crime lord’s got to have some kind of background music, right?  So the choices are:  do we do rubber puppets, or this sort of outlandish musical CG number.

chicagoreader.com
starwars.wikia.com






















Singer Sy Snootles – the puppet on left and CG on the right who looks a little more...uh.....  I think you have to see them in motion to get the effect, but….

I’d rather have no music, but Lucas doesn’t listen to me.  How much of a fanboy do I sound like, now?  (Except if I were a real fanboy, I’d be opting for rubber puppets.)   Lucas gets on a little soapbox in the DVD commentary about fans now complaining the Special Edition number and how it doesn’t look as real.  To which Lucas retorts, “none of it is real.”  Now what did you go and say that for, George?  Are we not as your fans entitled to an element of suspension of disbelief?


Rancor

This like the Empire strikes back had a problem with the matte lines.  They’ve been cleaned up.  Again, it doesn’t make waves and it leaves fans like me an appreciation for the challenges the optical effects guys had at the time.


Banthas

I suppose George wants us to see Banthas.  In A New Hope, a live Bantha is actually an elephant in costume.  


misc.thefullwiki.org



Now this is just a guess, but I’m betting it’s awfully expensive to get a whole herd of elephants and to make the costumes.   Then you have to put them on the animals, which I would think it not an easy or inexpensive task.  Nevertheless, through the magic of CG - some I know, are cringing - we have a herd of them before Jabba’s sail barge and the skiff on wich most of our heroes are awaiting their deaths at the hand of the “almighty sarlacc.”


Sarlacc

I think it looked fine in the theatrical version.  It was fascinating to see a hole and knowing there was some kind of creature in there.  The Special Edition changes have now given it a beak and tentacles, making it look like a little like the Audrey II plant from Little Shop of Horrors.

fitsnews.com

FEED ME!

Ewok Eyes

In the Blu-Ray version, they now blink.  A teddy bear with blinking eyes.  That makes bedtime more terrifying, doesn’t it?


Is that the same Emperor?

Many people thought since many things have been inserted to the various revisions in the Star Wars movies, that Ian McDiarmid had been inserted as the Emperor.  But that was Ian McDiarmid all those years ago, and he was about 35 at the time.  He just had a lot of latex on.  So really, he was brought back to the prequels to reprise his past self.  I’d advise not to overthink it, as one could get really confused.


Nooooooooo!  Not that!

Ohhohohoho - I zoom into the fanboy zone just like the multitudes of others who did not like this.  Before Vader throws his boss down into the chasm (what’s a Star Wars movie without a chasm or some other high place?), we hear a “Noooooooo” - that same agonizing cry that made many a fan cringe in Revenge of the Sith. 


patheos.com

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!...again
                                                                    
Why was that done?  I have no explanation.  I don’t think Lucas even appreciates how his films work when they do.  I thought that part of the power of Darth Vader’s character in Return of the Jedi is that I could almost see what’s going on behind that mask.  After Luke said, for example, “then my father is truly dead” Vader looks down over the edge of the walkway he is on.  We can see him deep in thought, perhaps contemplating what Luke said.  Fast forward to his son getting zapped by the Emperor.  He looks at Luke, looks at the Emperor, and then makes his decision.  We didn’t need any vocals for it.  Besides, some argue that it keeps Vader’s intentions a secret until the very last second, which it would have if you were seeing it for the first time.  The villain becomes the hero.  Lastly, there’s another thing: that Lucas doesn't realize how many times fans have seen this.  With the change made so long after the movie came out and after so many viewings, it clearly sounds wrong to fans including yours truly.


Death Star II destructive shock wave


silverscreensinners.blogspot.com

I don’t think there’s anything new here.  Want to move along?


Expanded ending vs. Yub Nub

For someone who has seen both versions of Return of the Jedi, there’s a world of difference between those endings, isn’t there?  A lot fans liked the original Yub Nub, but I hated it with a passion and thought it was an embarrassing way to end the whole saga.  It was like a kiddie tune.  Yes, I know it was the Ewoks’ song, but there’s a lot more going on, here.  Presumably, that is if you don’t consider the Expanded Universe canonical, the galaxy has just been liberated.  So we pan across many of the planets featured in the galaxy in celebration: Cloud City, Tatooine, Naboo (for the DVD) with an irritating Gungan “weesa free” and then Coruscant.  The blowing up of what we can presume as a statue of Palpatine is reminiscent of the end of the Cold War where statues of Lenin were being taken down.  Then we go back to the teddy bear planet.  And I particularly liked the music.  It was a sort of bring-it-on-home wrap-it-up and put-it-in-the-freezer music.

Hayden’s Head

And of course, one of the last shots we see is of the dead guys.  In the original theatrical version, Sebastian Shaw, who played the bald and scarred de-helmeted Anakin Skywalker was shown in the Jedi outfit just like Ben’s.  And he’s shown looking healthy and smiling (even though Sebastian Shaw who played him was 84 at the time and therefore really made up to look younger).  Now with the DVD and the prequels almost being over at the time, Hayden Christensen, the young bratty Anakin, has his head affixed to where in many peoples's opinion Shaw’s should be.  Some thought that was a good decision because the young Anakin is the Anakin Skywalker we want to see redeemed, not the old man.  But if you’re going to do that, why not just use Anakin’s whole Jedi costume, since we now know what it looks like.  And there are no dynamics with Hayden’s expression.  He just stares with a grin. 

aveleyman.com

"That's it, Hayden just...OK, that's fine."


And there’s also the idea that he died after Yoda and Obi-Wan did, but he comes back as the younger version of himself.  Is that fair?  I mean, he spent over 20 years on the dark side.


The Legacy

Fans seem to have many complaints, and there are many to whom the statement “this is just a movie” is like demolishing their souls.  But Lucasfilm refuses to issue purely original editions, citing that it wasn’t the direction the saga was headed in, and that the old negatives didn’t exist or some excuse like that.  Can’t we have a little nostalgia? ?  I think that’s what many of the fans are there for.  It’s either that or they are just or the purity of the movies.   What about the version that had me going crazy as a kid and annoying my classmates to no end?  This is what has fans making statements about what Lucas apparently did to their childhood.

Fans may be upset about the changes, but to me there’s a larger picture (no pun intended) here.  Film historians researching late 20th century cinema are going to be awfully confused when they start doing research, and most likely they will due to Star Wars’ contribution to popular culture.  The first Star Wars film isn’t the only movie with more than one version.  There are several films with Special Editions, Director’s Cuts, Rough Cuts, Theatrical Cuts, etc.  When I look at old films, I often try to think of how audiences have reacted, and I wonder if future film and cultural historians will, as well.  Star Wars was in the right place at the right time – a feel good movie.  Culturally, it came after much political, economic, and social upheaval.  Cinematically, it was a science fiction movie that followed many films that had a dystopian vision.  Film historians, and for that matter other historians, will want to know what about Star Wars had this effect on society.  But which one did it?  It’s certainly not the one that appears on Blu-Ray.  Is there a way we can get the other one back, even if it spends eternity in the film archives?



No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated for this blog.