Friday, March 29, 2013

Overthinking Star Wars: Them Changes, Part 3

Continued from Part 2

The Empire Strikes Back

Snow Monster

The snow creature - known as the wampa -breaks the neck of Luke’s mount (tauntaun), and knocks Luke out.  When Luke is in the cave, we see a new CG wampa munching away - probably on Luke’s tauntaun.  But the reason that he’s probably eating now is because even though he’s got probably the greatest and most energy efficient freezer, he probably doesn't have a grill or an outlet to plug the microwave in.  Or a microwave.  Or a conventional oven.  But I would think Luke would be eaten first because he is smaller and thus could be savored as an appetizer.  Maybe he’s going to be dessert.  Anyway, Luke is able to obtain his lightsaber through the Force, frees himself, and slices the creature’s arm off.  

the force.net
Profile view of a VERY, VERY, recently amputated wampa. 

The Blu-Ray bonus disc reveals wampas had a more visible role because they had broken into the base.  But these creatures looked more, well, fake. Like some evil albino cousins of Sully from Monsters, Inc.


Matte Lines

This is a technical area, and like I said, I’m not much of a technical person.  But I have to respect the special (optical) effects guys pulling off the challenging snow battle. The difficulty is that they were working with white backgrounds, and this was a challenge at the time.  One of the main problems was that the snow scenes would show through the black lines in the cockpit canopy.   Normally, you could hide this in a space battle, because the cockpit lines would simply be black on black.  Not so with the snow.  You had to make a choice about how much scenery you’re willing to see at the expense of the solid canopy line.  So ILM now got to fill in the black so that the cockpit lines are black and the scenery shows up.


Blue Artoo

I didn’t realize this until it was pointed out on a web page that I’m not sure exists anymore on this site.  When Artoo’s in the back seat in the X-wing in the original theatrical release, he’s actually black instead of blue.  The reason why is because that’s filmed against a bluescreen.  If Artoo was in his standard blue, he would be a victim of what is known as bluespill.  That would mean his blue parts would seem transparent, and we want ALL of Artoo there, don’t we?  Now the effects people can paint in the blue, or have a CG Artoo.


The Emperor

Ian McDiarmid, who plays Senator/Chancellor/Emperor Palpatine in the other movies except for A New Hope, is inserted into the Empire Strikes Back.

biobreak.wordpress.com
Originally, the Emperor had been a woman’s face superimposed with chimpanzee’s eyes and voiced by Clive Revill.
icollector.com
It made for a pretty eerie effect, but alas, continuity triumphs. But besides continuity, there is a slight, but significant change in the dialogue:

Original theatrical dialogue:
Emperor: We have a new enemy, Luke Skywalker.  He could destroy us.
Vader: He’s just a boy.  Obi-Wan can no longer help him.
Revised DVD dialogue:
Emperor:  We have a new enemy.  The young rebel who destroyed the Death Star.  I have no doubt this boy is the offspring of Anakin Skywalker.
Vader:  How is that possible?
Emperor: Search your feelings, Lord Vader.  You will know it to be true.  He could destroy us.
Vader: He’s just a boy.  Obi-Wan can no longer help him.

We see that in the revised dialogue, there’s something going on, given the opening crawl mentions that Vader is “obsessed with finding young Skywalker” and that, upon seeing the rebel base’s power generators transmitted from the probe droid, says “I am sure Skywalker is with them.”  This dialogue with Palpy implies that Vader is playing dumb and is up to something behind the Emperor’s back.  We remember from the prequels, agonizingly for some, that Anakin entered a Faustian pact and really lost everything from it except for being relatively well-placed in the Empire’s food chain.  And I would think that threatening, torturing, and choking wouldn’t lead to total job satisfaction or life fulfillment. Plus there's that faith of some "there is still good in him." At any rate, Vader may be seeing Luke as his ticket out of this mess.


Boba Fett

Again, continuity wins out.  Since Boba Fett is an exact clone of Jango Fett, who was played by Temuera Morrison, it only makes sense that Morrison would be voicing Boba Fett.  I miss hearing Jason Wingreen’s awesomely villainous voice, but Temuera Morrison’s doesn’t sound bad, either.  Certainly not enough to say my childhood has been violated.


Cloud City

We get an expanded view of Cloud City.  First, that additional scenery makes it longer for the Millennium Falcon to land.  Then the additional scene makes it longer to get an establishing shot of Leia in her new outfit pacing in the tower.  On the other hand, additional scenery makes the corridors not seem so claustrophobic and sterile.  So maybe that’s a good thing.  I don’t know.


Vader’s (Grrrrr) Return to His Ship

All right, this is where I put on my fanboy hat.  This first beef I have is with Vader's revised command for his shuttle.  What was wrong with keeping, “bring my shuttle?”  It was no-nonsense, and conveyed some anger on Vader’s part.  In the Special Edition, the line is changed to, “alert my star destroyer to prepare for my arrival.”  What kind of line is that?  And although relevant documentary evidence has long since vanished from the starwars.com web site, that’s not James Earl Jones’ voice.  If I remember correctly, it was an ILM-er, perhaps Don Bies.  A word of advice to anyone who wants to re-create a Vader scene: DO NOT under ANY CIRCUMSTANCES attempt to do so without James Earl Jones’ voice.


patheos.com


OK, so sometimes it doesn't always work even with James Earl Jones' voice.

Then Vader lands on what is supposedly his star destroyer.  I think Lucas et al may have underestimated the fanaticism of their fanatics, that we have seen Return of the Jedi many, many, many times.  We know this arrival is an alternate angle scene from when Vader lands on Death Star II.  This fan-made video does a pretty good job at convincingly inter-cutting the footage from Return of the Jedi and the Empire Strikes Back (the side views).


Pretty seamless, I’d say.  To me there's just no reason to establish him landing on his star destroyer.  I saw it as a 12-year-old for the first time, and I always assumed he got a little ride to his BIG ride.  No explanation necessary.


Next: Return of the Jedi


Sunday, March 24, 2013

Overthinking Star Wars: Them Changes, Part 2


Continued from Part 1

A New Hope (a.k.a. just "Star Wars")

Shockwaves When Things Done Get Blowed Up.

When both Alderaan and its assassin, the Death Star, get blown up, there’s a little augmentation on the explosion: A ring o’ shockwave. 
                                  
furiousfanboys.net
Alderaan

www.cnet.com.au


Death Star
And on we go…

No Flare

As Luke, Han, and Chewbacca blast their way first into the control room and then into the detention area, they shoot some guards.  Now the stuntmen/actors in these scenes had squibs – explosive charges on their bodies so they look like they are the unlucky recipients of laser fire.  The ones that were REALLY explosive were completely cut out even from the original theatrical version.  For the shots that remained in the movie, the micro fireballs that seemed to appear on their chests were not so firebally in the Special Edition.



thenexicon.com
Before Special Edition: abdomen on fire


drnorth.wordpress.com
Special Edition: not so much

Again, the reason is rumored to fall under the “Lucas has kids now” theory.

Aurebesh

This is the name given to the written language by the Expanded Universe that appears in the Star Wars movies.  It’s kind of a language that does imitate English in a rather coded way, but doesn’t openly resemble one language in particular.


ffffound.net

This puts the English-speaking viewer just as much at a disadvantage at reading the characters as the rest of the world.  That didn’t originally happen in the first movie.  And it was most manifested in the tractor beam lettering, where the words “power” and “tractor beam” showed up.  They no longer do.


Oh #%&$! More Stormtroopers

As Luke, Leia, Han, and Chewie split up into two separate groups, with Luke and Leia taking a swing.  Han and Chewie go after Stormtroopers, only to confront a whole bunch of them in a corner.  With the special edition changes, there’s a heck of a lot more of them in said corner, with even a parked TIE fighter, something we’ve never seen before.  Does it ruin the scene?  I don’t really think so.  Is it “necessary?”  I don’t really think so.  But it does but Han in a situation that calls for expletives.

Biggs Reunion

This actually came as a surprise to me as I saw the Special Edition of Star Wars the first showing on the first day and was never advertised, so I never had the chance to hear about it. The fans know that the character of Biggs, Luke’s best friend from Tatooine, spent most of his time on the cutting room floor.


blueharvest.net
Above: Biggs and Luke share a tender moment.


Biggs existed primarily to play off the character of Luke, because Lucas’ director buddies thought that Luke shouldn’t be introduced so late in the film and instead be introduced about the same time Leia was.  Lucas tried fitting those shots in and gave up, going back to his original plan: to start with the droids, following them to Luke, following Luke to Ben, Ben to Chewie, Chewie to Han, etc.

The only scene that shows Biggs outside of the dogfight is now this scene in the Rebel hangar, Luke is surprised when he reunites with his old friend.  Well, maybe not so surprised, because in the cut scenes, Biggs told nLuke he was going to join the Rebellion (that's what's really happening in the above picture.) Their brief exchange in the hangar is interrupted by Red Leader, their squadron commander, and through the magic of editing (someone walks by, and part of the shot is cut), Red Leader’s comment about how he met Luke’s father as a boy was still cut in this reunion scene.  He says how great of a pilot he was, and says that “If you have half the skill he had….” Then after the dude walks by what we see is the remainder of the shot and the end of Red Leader’s sentence, “…you’ll do all right.”

Now, I think we see why Lucas still left that part about Luke’s father out.  Lucas may not have had everything completely ironed out yet for the prequels, but he probably knew at this point leaving in that line might mess some things up.  We can see how, given the prequels the complications such as when did Red Leader meet Anakin and how did he know he was Luke’s father when Anakin’s children were kept secret?  Also, I’m not sure we really don’t want Luke to have half this father’s skill considering what Daddy Dearest had done.


killermovies,com
"I met your father once. He was a lightsaber-wielding homicidal maniac. Stay away from me, kid."

Now I pose this question to the fanboys…was this re-insertion a waste of time like the Jabba scene?  I mean, Biggs really doesn’t serve any other purpose than to be Luke’s wingman, only to get blasted by Darth Vader (gee, thanks Dad.  Most dads just simply forbid their kids to see their friends rather than KILL them).  He’s never mentioned again in any other movie.  But Jabba is mentioned throughout the original trilogy and is essential to what happens to Han.  So if the Jabba scene was unnecessary, wasn’t this one, as well?  I mean, without the scene, we see Luke get a nice sis kiss by Leia and he’s straight off to his spaceship without interruptions?  That’s good pacing, isn’t it?
 
OK, I’ll admit it.  I was happy to see that scene.  Sorry for wasting your time on that.

The Dogfight

What was advertised before the Special Edition came out were the rebel fighters scooting past the planet Yavin.  Lucasfilm really hyped up being able to see the pilots’ heads move.  But that was only part of it.  So much was changed in that battle that I, probably not unlike millions of other fans, had to go back home and get my pre-THX VHS version of the film to look at that and other changes.  And certainly there were.  For example, as the fighters were taking off.  The whole battle sequence was littered with change shots.  I think I understood that because many of the effects in that first film were starting to look dated.  Or at least I thought so when I saw it on my pre-THX VHS version 1990’s.  Oh.  I must say, the rebel fighters’ engines glowed in a gorgeous shade of pink in the Special Edition.


Fabulous

Throne Room

I don’t know if many people realized it, but most of the people in the throne room in the original theatrical version were painted in.  By doing that digital recreation thing, now “people” (I forgot if they’re actual people or just CGI) are now in the scene.  It’s just a subtle change but I guess it adds a dimension of realism to it.

Saturday, March 23, 2013

Overthinking Star Wars: Them Changes


Note:  I hope that it will be clear after the reading that finding out how the movies were made and of subsequent fan reaction was not something at which I arrived using my own intuition.  Those have been culled over the years from books, websites, and films.  Many of which I do not remember because I’m getting to be an old fan.
To try to make things less confusing for everyone, here are some terms I throw out throughout these blog entres:
  • ILM – Lucasfilm’s in-house visual and optical effects unit
  • EU – Explanded Universe.  These are tales told outside of the film through books, comic books, video games, etc.  They have given just about every character in the cantina scene a proper name, species, and a backstory.  Many fans consider this body to be canonical – that is, having as much value to the Star Wars saga as the movies themselves.  I’m not one of them J
  • Matte lines – outlines and other black marks on the outside and other part of objects created through the bluescreen process, paintings, and other visual elements.
  • CG or CGI – computer generated or computer generated imaging.  The source of most, if not all, of the changes controversy.


Okay, so every Star Wars fan has noticed and most certainly has an opinion of the changes in the Star Wars.  I am certainly one of them.   How serious are these changes?  Let’s discuss, shall we?


Prequels.


It’s nice that we know have a CG Yoda, but it’s also a little sad that the only piece of Frank Oz’s puppetry skills in this movie are lost.  But that Yoda in The Phantom Menace looked a little like the title characters in the movie Gremlins rather than the Yoda we saw in the original trilogy.  Now at least with the CG one there’s consistency, as he starts resembling the other versions of himself (sounds weird, doesn’t it).  Oh, Yeah in, AOTC I guess there’s now Shmi screaming in Anakin’s nightmares.
But we don’t care that much about what was done to the prequels, do we?  Let’s go to the movies that have really stirred up discussion.  Especially beginning with:

A New Hope (a.k.a. just “Star Wars”)


Before we get too far into this, I have to state that I am in no way a technical guy, and there are those who have analyzed the changes a lot more.  To go into the minutiae, I would recommend Wookiepedia.  This has all kinds of details like the timing of the opening crawl, and keeps track of the lightsaber color changes whereas I always lose track of them.  What I’ll deal with are some changes that I think have gotten more attention and emotional responses from fans.  Well, not all of them, but most.  Anyway...

Tatooine Evening

I particularly though it was a nice touch.  Artoo is abducted before nightfall, and the next day the sandcrawler they are aboard arrive at the Lars homestead.  In the original it was all daylight during the great droid hunt, then suddenly dusk when the Jawas brought their kill back to the sandcrawler.  Of course, that destroys my memories of all those stills in daylight featuring the Jawas and Artoo, but it’s still not enough to protest that George Lucas violated my childhood.

Stormtroopers Go a-Hunting

OK, what was originally a rubber dewback in the backfround in the original release now has now come to life via CGI.  This is all preceded by stormtroopers patrolling the desert sands (the new part takes place in Yuma and is merged with the original footage shot in Tunisia).  The new sequence features a stormtrooper riding a dewback with four stormtroopers, each moving on foot faster than the dewback, and the sand doesn’t seem to slow them down.  So: Why bother with the lizard?

The “Krayt Dragon Call”

For the not-so-nerdy, the Krayt (the name comes from the novelization) dragon call is what Ben (Obi-Wan) Kenobi uses to frighten the Sandpeople (aka Tusken Raiders) away when he is first introduced.  I think I recall many fan websites with information on the various changes.  But this last one in the Blu-Ray version was way different.  Why?  One possibility:  the original wail (or at least one of them) was much like the dewback, or probably was the dewback.  I lose track, and don’t pay too much attention…until the Blu-Ray.  So I guess the justification for the changes is that a creature indigenous to Tatooine is less likely to freak out the Tuskens.  Or at least, that’s my guess.  The new yell is also a little more terrifying.

Artoo In His Hiding Place        

This was an interesting change in the Blu-Ray version.  It shows Artoo hidden behind a bunch of rocks.  There is, however, no way of determining how he maneuvered in and out of it.


kool.cbslocal.com
Above: before Blu-Ray changes.  Below: Blu-Ray changes
How’d he get in there?
+

Luke, Ma.  No Wheels!

I’ll wait until you finish groaning.  The scenes of the landspeeder zooming across the desert had an obscured bottom in the theatrical version.  The life-sized landspeeder had wheels that either at times had mirrors or in the case of the Mos Eisley scenes, there was Vaseline smeared across the bottom of the lens. This rather blurry underside was jokingly referred to as the “force field.”  Now it’s all cleaned up and the landspeeder is…oh….floating on air…


http://cerebralmastication.blogspot.com
Yippee

 

Mos Eisley Exteriors

One thing I liked about the changes is that since…you know…the place is called Mos Eisley SPACEPORT, you would expect to see more ships than the Millennium Falcon.  And you’d expect it to be a little busier.  And that appears to be the case with he Special Edition.  Also, there are additional creatures and probe robots.  I wonder who the lucky ones are who have to clean up the mess. That is, from the animals, not the robots.

And oh yes, we are SO going there…


Yup: It’s Han Shoots First…OR Is It Greedo That Shoots First?

I don’t think a change has had many fans lighting torches and sharpening pitchforks more than this.  My initial response when seeing the Special Edition in the theater was “Wait, something’s different about it."  And boy was it.  The original scene, which I at least think I remember as well as anyone else, has Greedo saying that he “has been looking forward to this (killing Han) for a very long time.”  Han retorts, ”Yes, Ill bet you have.”  There is a flash, and next is a clear two-shot with Han and Greedo’s head – attached to his smoldering body- dropping onto the table. The new version that has been there since then has Greedo firing first, and then Han firing, and Greedo’s head – attached to his smoldering body- dropping onto the table.

Lucas has said that Greedo always shot first.

quickmeme.com



















Even with that change, my initial thought to the fan outrage was, “Go back to your mother’s basement and take some REALLY deep breaths.  It’s nothing to get upset about.”  I just thought it really didn’t change things that much.  I didn’t think it changed the plot at all.

But as I heard more of the fans’ complaints, I began to see things from their viewpoint.  The plot was really not the issue.  The issue was the character development of Han Solo that was not being maximized by this scene alteration.  When we first meet him, he’s a smuggler.  His work is illegal and he therefore risks getting caught by imperial authorities, and we have to assume imperial law enforcement is not merciful.  He has to seek the protection which puts at the mercy of some very crooked characters.  His work is dangerous.  And here he is, out for himself until he decides over the course of the movie to be a part of something greater than himself (that’s Joseph Campbell’s explanation, which I really like and I think I’ll steal).  Having Greedo shoot first takes away somewhat from his self-centered pirate character.  Sure Han kills Greedo in self-defense, but shooting first means that he’s not taking any chances and let the other guy get a shot off.  It makes him the rugged loner in a kill-or-be-killed galaxy.  Kind of like a western.

In a bonus Blu-Ray disc, the original dialogue in the scene filmed in England (before it was re-done with Greedo's moving ears and mouth in California) had Greedo being there for no other reason than to kill Han.  And he was really, really enthusiastic about doing it.  Regardless if Greedo seems to enjoy his job as a hired assassin, we might expect him to at least be able to aim more accurately at near point-blank range.  That shot was not only wasted, it was sad.

So why was the scene re-done, anyway?  One fan theory – or rumor - goes (at least I think it’s a fan theory) is that Lucas didn’t realized he had kids and didn’t want them to see the hero murder someone in cold blood (or something like that).


The Jabba Scene

This I think is related to the Greedo Scene.  I was excited to see the Jabba scene, because it was one of those scenes – like the Biggs scenes (to be explained later) - that I knew always existed and that I finally would see, even though I know full well it was re-touched.  Other fans did not agree.  One of the minor ones is that it wasn't the same immobile slug in Return of the Jedi   I say big deal.  So you don’t get your sophisticated puppet.  Why can’t we just say the guy ate too many of those frogs or whatever they were between then and Return of the Jedi.  Being a crime boss is lonely, and you don’t get to experience real meaningful friendships.  Maybe he just ate a lot of comfort food for his loneliness.  That’s plausible, isn’t it? 


slaveleia.wikia.com
OM NOM NOM NOM  *sigh* *sniff*

But where the fans seem to have their strongest point is that it disrupted the pacing of the movie and was therefore unnecessary.  Let’s look at that view.  George Lucas filmed the scene with actor Declan Mulholland.  His original intention was either to matte come kind of slug head on him or to somehow replace him with a stop-motion animation character.  

rottentomatoes.com

On the right, a decidedly non-CGI Jabba

When Lucas realized he was running out of time and he wasn’t going to finish the scene, he transferred most of Jabba’s dialogue to Greedo.  Han, while pulling his gun from the holster under the table in his confrontation with Greedo, says the line “Even I get boarded sometimes.  Do you think I had a choice?”  If you compare that with the Jabba scene, you realize that line was actually dubbed into the Greedo confrontation from that scene. 

So what do we get from the Jabba scene now that it’s in?   Well, we get that:
·         What Jabba looks like, sort of.
·         Han is not intimidated by Jabba.  There are many examples of this:
o   He tells him angrily to not send one of his “twerps”
o   He steps on Jabba’s tail, which steamed off some fans.  But this was Lucas’ solution to a problem the animators were having because Han went around the human Jabba, but would be running through the CGI Jabba’s tail.  But his expression did go from an “ouch” in the 1997 Special Edition to a why-you-I’m-gonna-smack-you expression in the Blu-Ray
o   Jabba says “For an extra 20%”, Han counters, “15, don’t push it”

So what else do we have? Anyone?  Oh yeah, the insertion of Boba Fett.  Yeah, anyway…

Takeoff From Mos Eisley

Okay, CGI Millennium Falcon taking off from the docking bay.  The circular hole structure kind of sets things up for Episode II when the Naboo cruiser lands.


legopunk.com

Above: An awesome Lego artists’ rendering of the Docking Bay